Ratings & Reviews

I just want to say how blown away I am at everything Libby’s Sugar Shop!! From price, to taste, to design, to execution! I gave Libby some inspiration photos for my son’s Outlaw themed birthday, she made the cutest and most perfect cookies. You cannot beat her prices either. Also, she accommodated me by rushing my order a day early (endlessly grateful for her making my cookies a day earlier than scheduled- when I messed up!) you truly are the best Libby!!!

It was so beautiful and extremely delicious! The cake itself was so good and the almond icing was perfect! I love it!

The cookies were delicious and beautifully decorated!

Absolutely amazing!! The cookies were not only beautiful but delicious! And the cupcakes were perfect as well!! Highly recommend Libby and we will definitely be using her again!!!

This is probably my fifth order and I love everything more and more each time I order from her! The flavor is so delicious. The quality is unmatched and she’s very quick and professional! Highly recommend ordering!

She has done AMAZING for every order I’ve placed! The cookies are almost too perfect to to eat!

Absolutely beautiful cookies for a wedding rehearsal. They were perfect and exactly what I had in mind.

Libby’s Cookies are the absolute best!! They are always so cute and make every party just that much better!! They are exactly what we were wanting and the taste of her cookies are also really good!!

First off, Libby was super easy to work with. Talked everything over and made our plan. Then we picked up the cake and it exceeded my expectations for sure!! It was EXACTLY as my son wanted and it was beautiful! Then party time came & everyone raved about the cake and how delicious it was! I had to sneak a piece out early to make sure I had one and good thing I did, because it was completely gone in 2 hours! HIGHLY RECOMMEND LIBBY’S!!

Just wanted to do a shout out for Libby, doing the cutest Mudder's Day Cookies. Also thanks for helping me out because of my schedule. They are going to love these!! Support Hometown Businesses Everyone..She is AWESOME! 👍

Had the best experience ordering custom cookies for our daughter’s birthday. The cookies turned out wonderful and tasted amazing!

Loved the cookies. Great taste and were decorated perfectly.

We were so pleased with our cookies for my granddaughters 2nd birthday. The theme was 2 Wild and she nailed it. Not only were they absolutely beautiful. They tasted amazing. They were a Huge topic at the party.

Libby’s cookies were absolutely fantastic! I had very specific ideas and super high expectations and she went above and beyond in her execution — I couldn’t have imagined them looking or tasting anything better. 5 stars!!!

She did such an amazing job on my sons birthday cake. The cake was so beautiful and turned out exactly how I envisioned it to turn out! Highly recommend!

Beautiful cake and taste so good. I needed a cake at the last minute with less than 2 days notice she came through and saved the day. ❤️

You wouldn’t believe how amazing this pink rainbow birthday cake is. It's like a magical explosion of colors and sweetness. The cake layers are so moist and fluffy, and the frosting is like a dream. Trust me, every bite is pure happiness! Libby never disappoints!

I’ve been beyond impressed every time I’ve ordered from Libby. Taste, decor and style are all top notch.

I had a great experience ordering from this small business!! My cookies came out perfect, and on time even with my short notice. Pick up was easy and fast. I would definitely order again!!

I ordered a strawberry on strawberry cake and it was the most delicious and most moist cake I have had in a long time! I also ordered very short notice and she was able to accommodate. I will definitely be ordering more cakes through Libby’s sugar shop!

I asked Libby to make a cake and cupcakes incorporating my granddaughter’s favorite show Mayta. I had no idea how she would do it but Libby was up to the challenge! She created a work of art and it was a hit!

The cookies were perfect! They were gorgeous, delicious, and fit my theme perfectly!

The prefect cookies! Even better than the inspo pictures I sent her!