Customer Favorites
The Signature Dozen
Shelly’s Sentiments is excited to present a curated selection of our signature gourmet cupcakes. Each box features handcrafted gourmet cupcakes selected by Shelly. This week’s flavors include: 🍪 Biscoff Cookie Butter • vanilla cupcake filled with cookie butter with vanilla buttercream, drizzled with cookie butter topped with Biscoff Cookies. 🍫 Chocolate Fudge •chocolate cupcake with vanilla buttercream, drizzled with chocolate and topped with chocolate sprinkles. 🥜 Reese’s Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup •chocolate cupcake with peanut butter spread, chocolate mousse buttercream, topped with peanut butter sprinkles and Reese’s cup. 🍫 Chocolate Peanut Butter •chocolate cupcake with peanut butter spread, vanilla buttercream, drizzled with chocolate sauce and topped with chocolate sprinkles. 🍮 Caramel Vanilla •vanilla cupcake filled with caramel topped with vanilla buttercream and drizzled with caramel sauce. 🎪 Circus Animal •vanilla cupcake with vanilla buttercream, topped with rainbow nonpareil sprinkles and Mother’s Original Circus Animal Cookie.
$50.00
Wedding Cake
Starting at $500.00
“Boo” Treat Box
1 dozen assorted treats 3 Chocolate covered Oreos 3 chocolate covered rice krispy 3 chocolate covered pretzel twists 3 cake pops
$25.00
Custom Edible Drink Toppers
Please let us know what you are looking for. Upload inspiration and let us know sizes you are looking for.
Starting at $12.00
Strawberry Shortcake Bowls
Delicious layers of our vanilla cake, fresh strawberries and our fresh whipped cream frosting
$5.00
Shooters
Available banana pudding (original, strawberry, Oreo) and cheesecake (strawberry, Oreo, cookie butter)
$35.00
Jewish Apple Cake - Slice
$7.00
Shelly’s Signature Banana Bliss (mixed Pudding)
Our classic banana pudding blended to perfection — layers of fresh bananas, creamy vanilla pudding, and buttery Chessmen cookies folded together into one smooth, dreamy bite. Rich, nostalgic, and made with love, this is comfort in a cup and bliss in every spoonful.
$5.00
4 Way Cheesecake Sampler
Why choose one when you can have four? Indulge in our rich, creamy cheesecake collection featuring: • Oreo – Smooth vanilla cheesecake loaded with crushed Oreos and topped with cookie crumble. • Strawberry – Classic cheesecake swirled and crowned with sweet strawberry topping. • Cookie Butter – Decadent cheesecake infused with warm, spiced cookie butter flavor and a luscious drizzle. • Banana Pudding – Creamy cheesecake layered with fresh bananas and buttery cookie crumble for a nostalgic twist on a classic favorite.
$12.00
Sweet Potato Cheesecake Layer Cake
$7.00
Heart Cakes
Starting at $150.00
Cupcakes
$25.00
Single Tier Cakes
Starting at $150.00
Mini Cakes
$6.00
Caramel Apple Cheesecake - Whole
$50.00
4 Way Banana Pudding Sampler
Why choose one when you can have four? Indulge in our rich, creamy banana pudding collection featuring: • Oreo • Strawberry • Cookie Butter • Classic Banana Pudding
$12.00
Pumpkin Cheesecake - Whole
$50.00
2 Tier Cakes
Starting at $200.00
Sweet Potato Cheesecake - Whole
$50.00
Chocolate Covered Oreos
$30.00
Custom Carved Cakes
Starting at $350.00
Shelly’s Monthly Cake Box
4 Full Size Cake Slices *no substitutions October’s flavors: •Banana Pudding •Apple Strudel •Triple Chocolate •Birthday Cake
$25.00
Pumpkin Pie
$30.00
Chocolate Covered Pretzel Rods
$20.00
Sweet Potato Bread
$25.00
Sweet Potato Pie
$30.00
Custom Cakes
Wedding Cake
Starting at $500.00
Sampler
Starting at $25.00
Heart Cakes
Starting at $150.00
Single Tier Cakes
Starting at $150.00
2 Tier Cakes
Starting at $200.00
Custom Carved Cakes
Starting at $350.00
3 Tier Cake
Starting at $300.00
Daily Menu
Peach Cobbler Pound Cake
$65.00
Strawberry Shortcake Bowls
Delicious layers of our vanilla cake, fresh strawberries and our fresh whipped cream frosting
$5.00
Shelly’s Signature Banana Bliss (mixed Pudding)
Our classic banana pudding blended to perfection — layers of fresh bananas, creamy vanilla pudding, and buttery Chessmen cookies folded together into one smooth, dreamy bite. Rich, nostalgic, and made with love, this is comfort in a cup and bliss in every spoonful.
$5.00
4 Way Cheesecake Sampler
Why choose one when you can have four? Indulge in our rich, creamy cheesecake collection featuring: • Oreo – Smooth vanilla cheesecake loaded with crushed Oreos and topped with cookie crumble. • Strawberry – Classic cheesecake swirled and crowned with sweet strawberry topping. • Cookie Butter – Decadent cheesecake infused with warm, spiced cookie butter flavor and a luscious drizzle. • Banana Pudding – Creamy cheesecake layered with fresh bananas and buttery cookie crumble for a nostalgic twist on a classic favorite.
$12.00
Strawberry Shortcake Jar
$8.00
4 Way Banana Pudding Sampler
Why choose one when you can have four? Indulge in our rich, creamy banana pudding collection featuring: • Oreo • Strawberry • Cookie Butter • Classic Banana Pudding
$12.00
Shelly’s Monthly Cake Box
4 Full Size Cake Slices *no substitutions October’s flavors: •Banana Pudding •Apple Strudel •Triple Chocolate •Birthday Cake
$25.00
Party Treat Packages
Brownies
A dozen brownies
$25.00
Shooters
Available banana pudding (original, strawberry, Oreo) and cheesecake (strawberry, Oreo, cookie butter)
$35.00
Mini Cakesicles
$40.00
Cupcakes
$25.00
Mini Cakes
$6.00
Chocolate Covered Rice Krispy Treats
$30.00
Chocolate Covered Oreos
$30.00
Chocolate Covered Pretzel Rods
$20.00
Chocolate Covered Strawberries
$35.00
Custom Order
Cake Pops Heart shaped Red and white 3 dozen
Starting at $1.00
Cake Pops
Starting at $35.00
Custom Decorated Cookies
$45/dozen for 2 designs, $55/dozen for 3 designs, $65/dozen for 4 designs
Starting at $45.00
Fall Menu
Caramel Apple Pecan Pound Cake
$65.00
Sweet Potato Cheesecake - Slice
$7.00
Jewish Apple Cake - Slice
$7.00
Sweet Potato Cheesecake Layer Cake
$7.00
Caramel Apple Cheesecake - Whole
$50.00
Pumpkin Cheesecake - Whole
$50.00
Sweet Potato Cheesecake - Whole
$50.00
Pumpkin Pie
$30.00
Sweet Potato Bread
$25.00
Sweet Potato Pie
$30.00
Non Custom Cake
Pina Colada Cake
8 inch Layers of coconut cake with pineapple filling, coconut buttercream icing topped with toasted coconut and pineapple
$50.00
Butter Crunch Cookie Cake (Topper Not Included)
8 inch Layers of butter cake with our classic vanilla buttercream icing, topped with Crunch Cookies and caramel sauce
$65.00
Reese’s Peanut Butter Cake (Topper Not Included)
8 inch chocolate cake layers, peanut butter frosting topped with Reese’s peanut butter cups and chocolate drip
$65.00
Classic Strawberry Shortcake
8 Classic strawberry shortcake, vanilla cake layers with fresh strawberry filling and whipped cream icing, topped with fresh strawberries
$50.00
Chocolate Cherry
8 inch chocolate cake with cherry buttercream, chocolate drip, garnished with chocolate shreds and cherries
$65.00
Chocolate Birthday Cake
6 inch Chocolate cake with our classic vanilla buttercream icing and sprinkles
$45.00
Strawberry Crunch Cake With Cheesecake
Two layers of strawberry cake with cheesecake layer between
$65.00
Red Velvet Cake
8 inch chocolate cake with cherry buttercream, chocolate drip, garnished with chocolate shreds and cherries
$65.00
About
✨ Luxury Custom Cakes & Signature Desserts
📍 Camden, NJ Dessert Studio
👩🏽🍳 Crafted by Shelly
🎂 Elegant designs. Memorable flavors. Unforgettable celebrations.
Capabilities & Pricing
A 50% non-refundable deposit is required to secure date. Deposit is required within 24 hours of receipt of invoice. If Deposit is not received, invoice will be cancelled. Balance would be due 2 days before pick-up/delivery (one month before event for Wedding Orders) Orders aren't fulfilled unless paid in full. Cancellation must be made 24-48 hours prior to event date. There is a $25 rebooking fee, if necessary.
Policies
Powered by
